Reasons for Dismissing an Employee

Dismissing an employee can be complex, but understanding the legal landscape and following best practice can help ensure fairness and minimises business risk.

Understanding employee dismissals

Navigating the process of dismissing an employee is an important responsibility for any employer in Australia. It goes beyond simply ending an employee's employment - it involves understanding the legal parameters, ensuring fairness throughout the process, and protecting your business from potential risks.

Think of it this way, dismissing an employee without proper justification is not only unfair to the individual but also carries legal and financial implications for your business. The Fair Work Commission has issued numerous rulings highlighting the risks associated with wrongful termination. This highlights the importance of fully understanding the circumstances under which dismissal is considered fair and legally sound.

By equipping yourself with this knowledge, you can make informed decisions regarding employee terminations, ensuring compliance with the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Act) and minimising the potential for costly unfair dismissal claims.

Dismissing an Employee

Valid reasons for dismissal

Dismissing an employee is a decision that shouldn't be taken lightly. As an employer, you're entrusted with someone's livelihood, and ending their employment should only be considered after careful thought and with proper justification.

Reacting to an employee's behaviour might seem tempting, but the Fair Work Commission emphasises the importance of valid, sound, and defensible reasons for dismissal. This, coupled with a fair dismissal process, are important considerations to minimise the risk of an unfair dismissal claim.

Remember, unfair dismissal claims can arise for employees who've met the minimum employment period (6 or 12 months depending on your business size). So, before making any decisions, ensure you have legitimate grounds and a fair approach in place.

Now that we've established the importance of valid reasons and fair processes, here are four key reasons outlined in the Fair Work Act:

  1. Capacity refers to situations where an employee, despite reasonable support and training, lacks the fundamental skills or abilities to fulfill the essential requirements of their role. It's important to assess their capability objectively and document any steps taken to assist them before considering dismissal.
  2. Performance focusses on an employee's consistent underperformance relative to the expectations outlined in their job description or employment contract. This could involve a lack of necessary skills, poor quality work, or a failure to meet deadlines despite warnings and improvement opportunities.
  3. Misconduct encompasses serious behaviour or conduct that violate company policies, breach the terms of employment, or constitute unlawful conduct. Examples include theft, harassment, discrimination, or violence. The severity of the misconduct and its impact on the workplace will determine the appropriateness of dismissal.
  4. Redundancy occurs when a specific role is no longer required due to restructuring, technological advancements, or economic changes. When redundancy is the reason, clear selection criteria and consultation with affected employees are crucial to ensure fairness and compliance with the law.

It's important to remember that even if an employee doesn't have access to an unfair dismissal claim, other reasons for dismissal might still present risk for your business. The Fair Work Act 2009 outlines situations where dismissing an employee could be unlawful, even if they don't qualify for unfair dismissal claims. These situations involve employee rights, workplace actions, and equal treatment that can result in general protections claims.

Conducting fair employee dismissals

Dismissing an employee, regardless of the reason, demands careful consideration and a procedurally fair process. The Fair Work Commission assesses the fairness of each dismissal based on whether it was "harsh, unjust, or unreasonable" in the specific context.

It's widely accepted that employers should follow a fair and transparent process before terminating employment. This involves:

  • Clearly communicating the reasons for potential dismissal by outlining the concerns or allegations and provide the employee with an opportunity to respond.
  • Granting time to prepare a response by allowing the employee sufficient time to gather information and potentially involve a support person if needed.
  • Following documented procedures if your business has established and outlined dismissal procedures within your employee handbook or company policies.

During the dismissal process, it's important to provide employees the opportunity to present their perspective and respond to concerns. Carefully consider their explanations and any evidence they provide before reaching a decision. While you may weigh the likelihood of allegations being true based on available information, remember that fairness often outweighs an assessment on the balance of probabilities.

Ultimately, even if concerns seem substantiated, the specific context might render dismissal harsh, unjust, or unreasonable. Alternative solutions, like warnings, performance improvement plans, or mediation, could be more appropriate depending on the circumstances.

Ensuring a fair and compliant dismissal process involves more than just valid reasons. Following established procedures and treat employees with respect throughout the process to ensure

Considering the complexities involved in dismissal procedures, seeking support from HR specialists can offer valuable peace of mind. Employment Compass offers a team of HR consultants ready to support your business. Call our 24/7 Employer Assist Line on 1300 144 002 for more information.

Frequently asked questions

What are the legal implications of dismissing an employee in Australia?

Dismissing an employee without valid reasons or a fair process can lead to costly unfair dismissal claims. The Fair Work Act outlines four main categories of valid reasons for dismissal: capacity, performance, misconduct, and redundancy.

Can my business be taken to the Fair Work Commission for constructive dismissal?

Yes. Constructive dismissal occurs when you, as the employer, make it unreasonably difficult for an employee to continue working, essentially forcing them to quit. Examples include significant pay cuts, unreasonable changes to working conditions, bullying, or harassment. If an employee feels they had no reasonable choice but to resign due to your actions, it could be classified as constructive dismissal and lead to legal action.

What are some actions that automatically qualify as unfair dismissal in Australia?

The Fair Work Act outlines specific situations where dismissal is automatically considered unfair, regardless of performance or conduct. These include:

  • Discrimination - dismissing based on protected characteristics like race, gender, age, disability, or religious beliefs.
  • Exercising workplace rights - terminating someone for joining a union, requesting flexible work arrangements, or taking legitimate leave.
  • Temporary absences - firing someone for taking authorised leave for illness, parental leave, or other valid reasons.

If you dismiss an employee for any of these reasons, you could face significant legal consequences.

Can I fire someone immediately for serious misconduct?

In rare and severe cases, you may utilise summary dismissal. This involves immediate termination without prior warnings or opportunities to respond, typically reserved for serious misconduct like theft, violence, or endangering workplace safety. Due to its gravity, legal advice is important before considering summary dismissal, ensuring you meet the strict criteria and follow proper procedures.

Is unfair dismissal the only legal concern when firing an employee?

Unfair dismissal is one aspect, but wrongful dismissal encompasses broader situations where termination breaches legal requirements or employment contracts. This could include:

  • Unfair dismissal - dismissing someone without valid reasons or a fair process.
  • Breach of contract - violating any agreed-upon terms in the employee's contract regarding termination.
  • Discrimination - dismissal based on protected characteristics, even if not automatic unfair dismissal.

Have a question?

We're available 24/7. Call our Workplace Relations specialists now or contact us below.

Let's resolve your workplace question.

By submitting my contact details, I confirm that I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and the Privacy Policy. I consent to you contacting me about Employment Compass services.

Thank you

Thanks for reaching out. We will get back to you soon.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.