Employee versus Independent Contractor

This guide clarifies the differences between employees and independent contractors, covering key aspects like work arrangements, rights, and the legal implications of sham contracting.

Understanding the distinction between an employee and an independent contractor is crucial, as it's not always immediately clear. The key difference lies in the nature of the contract: an employment relationship is a 'contract of service,' while an independent contractor relationship is a 'contract for service.'

An employee typically works under the direction of the employer, following set hours and organisational processes. In contrast, an independent contractor runs their own business and offers specific services. They often have more control over how and when they complete their tasks. However, even these factors alone might not be sufficient to definitively categorise someone as an employee or an independent contractor. It's essential to consider the entire relationship and the specific terms of the contract to make an accurate determination.

When distinguishing between an employee and an independent contractor, courts or tribunals consider the entire relationship, employing a multi-factor test that includes:

  1. Control Over Work: How much control the employer has over how and when the work is done.
  2. Hours of Work: Whether the worker has set hours or flexible hours.
  3. Ongoing Work Expectation: If there's an expectation of continuous work.
  4. Financial Risk: The degree of financial risk assumed by the worker.
  5. Tools and Equipment: Who provides the necessary tools and equipment.
  6. Payment Method: How the worker is paid (e.g., salary vs. invoice).
  7. Leave Entitlements: Whether the worker has standard employment leave benefits.
  8. Work for Other Companies: The ability of the worker to provide services to other companies.
  9. Delegation/Subcontracting Rights: Whether the worker has the right to delegate tasks or subcontract the work.

Misrepresenting this relationship as per the Fair Work Act 2009 can lead to a sham contracting arrangement, which is a serious offence. It's important for employers to accurately define and understand these relationships to ensure compliance with employment laws.

Contractor vs Subcontractor

The roles of contractor and subcontractor, while similar in name, function differently and have distinct agreements.

Contractors, operating as businesses, negotiate work scope, including project timelines, work hours, services, and payment methods. They take on projects with the responsibility to deliver the complete result to their clients.

Subcontractors are often employed by contractors to perform specific tasks within a larger project that the contractor may not have the expertise or resources to complete. For instance, a building contractor might hire a roofing subcontractor for a home renovation project. In this case, the subcontractor works under the contractor, not directly for the client.

The subcontractor agreement, then, is a contract between the contractor and the subcontractor. This agreement outlines the terms of their working relationship, detailing the subcontractor's duties, payment terms, and other essential aspects specific to their contribution to the project. Understanding the nuances of these roles and their agreements is crucial for managing responsibilities and expectations in project-based work.

Contractor Services

Independent contractors can set their own rates and terms for the work they do since they run their own businesses. They don't get the usual benefits that employees receive from their employers, like paid leave or allowances.

On the other hand, employees work according to their employer's instructions and get various benefits like leave and extra pay for certain conditions. Employers are responsible for managing these benefits and keeping track of them. This is a big difference between hiring someone as an employee and hiring them as an independent contractor.

Contractor Rights And Protections

Although independent contractors run their own businesses, they still have certain workplace rights under the Fair Work Act. These protections cover both the independent contractor and the principal (the person or entity engaging the contractor's services), including those contractors who are proposed to be engaged.

Key protections for independent contractors include:

  • Protection from coercion where they should not be forced or pressured into certain actions or decisions.
  • Protection from adverse action where they shouldn't be treated unfairly for exercising their rights.
  • Protection for freedom of association where they have the right to join or not join industrial associations without repercussions.

Additionally, contractors have the right to make complaints, inquiries, or initiate proceedings under workplace laws to ensure these laws are followed. This means if a contractor believes a workplace right has been violated, they can take steps to address this issue legally. For business owners, understanding these rights is crucial to ensure fair and lawful treatment of independent contractors.

Adverse action occurs when a principal (the person or business engaging an independent contractor) takes negative actions against a contractor (or potential contractor) for exercising their protected rights. This could include rights related to workplace issues or the right to participate in industrial activities. Examples of adverse actions include:

  1. Refusing to Hire or Terminating the Contract: Not engaging the contractor or ending their contract because they exercised a protected right.
  2. Discriminatory Terms: Offering worse terms or conditions to the contractor because they used a protected right.
  3. Injuring in Contract Terms: Causing harm to the contractor in the context of their contract terms and conditions.
  4. Changing Position to Disadvantage: Altering the contractor's role or conditions in a way that disadvantages them.
  5. Refusal to Use Services: Not using or agreeing to use the services offered by the contractor.
  6. Refusing to Supply Goods or Services: Not providing or agreeing to provide goods or services to the contractor.

It's important for business owners to understand that these actions, when taken in response to a contractor exercising their legal rights, are considered unlawful under the Fair Work Act. This understanding helps ensure fair treatment of independent contractors and compliance with workplace laws.

It's important to note that the protections under the Fair Work Act extend to the principal (employer or business engaging an independent contractor) as well. The principal is protected in cases where the independent contractor might respond negatively to the principal's legitimate exercise of rights under workplace laws. Such reactions from the independent contractor could include:

  1. Ceasing Work: The contractor stopping work under the contract.
  2. Taking Industrial Action: The contractor engaging in industrial actions against the principal.

These protections ensure that while independent contractors are safeguarded against unfair treatment, the principals are also protected against unwarranted actions by contractors. This balance is crucial for maintaining fair and lawful interactions in the workplace.

Sham Contracting

Sham contracting is a serious issue under the Fair Work Act 2009, where an employer incorrectly represents a worker as an independent contractor instead of an employee. This can be intentional or due to misunderstanding the nature of the employment arrangement, but either way, it has significant implications. It can affect the worker's leave accrual, penalty rates, and notice of termination.

The Act strictly prohibits engaging in sham contracting. This includes:

  1. Misrepresenting an Employee: Claiming an employee is an independent contractor.
  2. Forcing a Change in Status: Pressuring an existing employee to become an independent contractor.
  3. Dismissal Threats: Dismissing or threatening to dismiss an employee for refusing to become an independent contractor.
  4. Re-engagement as Contractor: Terminating an employee to then engage them as an independent contractor for the same role.
  5. Misleading an Employee: Deceiving an employee into becoming an independent contractor to perform the same or similar work.

Penalties can apply for contravening these provisions. It's crucial for employers to understand the differences between an employee and an independent contractor, as there is no single determining factor, and each situation is assessed individually. To assist with managing employee entitlements and avoiding sham contracting, tools like BrightHR can be valuable. Understanding and correctly classifying employment relationships are key to compliance and fair treatment in the workplace.

When determining whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor, consider these key factors:

  1. The degree of control the worker has over their work.
  2. The ability of the worker to delegate tasks to others.
  3. Whether the worker has the right to perform work for multiple companies.
  4. If the work is ongoing or for a specific project or task.
  5. Who provides the necessary tools and equipment for the job.
  6. How the worker is compensated (e.g., salary vs. invoice).
  7. Whether the worker receives standard employee leave benefits.

Remember, this list isn't exhaustive and each situation should be assessed on its own merits.

For assistance in understanding the nuances between contractors and employees, you can contact the Employment Compass Employer Helpline at 1300 144 002.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I Have to Pay my Contractors’ Super?

This question is best directed to the Australian Taxation Office, as superannuation obligations can vary.

What Is An Independent Contractor In Australia?

Independent Contractors run their own businesses and are engaged for specific services. They use their own tools, set their own hours, negotiate fees, and can work for multiple clients.

What Is The Difference Between An Employee And An Independent Contractor?

Employees work under an employer's direction with set hours and methods. Independent contractors run their own business, negotiate their terms, and have more autonomy in how they complete their work.

Is It Better To Hire An Employee Or An Independent Contractor?

The choice depends on your business needs, the nature of the work, and the desired flexibility in the working relationship.

How Many Hours A Week Can An Independent Contractor Work?

Independent Contractors set their own hours, typically working as needed to complete the task within the agreed timeframe.

Do Independent Contractors Have Any Rights?

Yes, they have rights under Contract Law and are also protected under the Fair Work Act from coercion, adverse action, and abuses of freedom of association.

Is Sham Contracting Illegal?

Yes, sham contracting, where employment is misrepresented as an independent contractor arrangement to avoid entitlements, is illegal and can have serious legal consequences.

Have a question?

We're available 24/7. Call our Workplace Relations specialists now or contact us below.

Let's resolve your workplace question.

By submitting my contact details, I confirm that I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and the Privacy Policy. I consent to you contacting me about Employment Compass services.

Thank you

Thanks for reaching out. We will get back to you soon.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.